Two state senators file lawsuit to block Colorado’s new progressive income tax

DENVER — Two state senators have filed a lawsuit to block Colorado from collecting higher income taxes approved by voters under Amendment 87, according to a complaint dated Thursday.

Senators Barbara Kirkmeyer of Weld County and Byron Pelton of Logan County, both Republicans, filed the suit in Denver District Court as individual taxpayers.

They are suing Gov. Jared Polis and Heidi Humphreys, executive director of the Colorado Department of Revenue, in their official capacities.

top-stories.mp4

You can read the full lawsuit below

Amendment 87 was adopted on November 6 with 51.72% of the vote. According to the complaint, he amended the state constitution and increased personal and corporate income tax rates.

“The Colorado Constitution is explicit: taxes cannot be increased without prior voter approval, and voters must be accurately informed before voting,” the complaint states.

The senators put forward two arguments.

The arguments of the trial

Kristi Burton Brown, executive vice president of the Advance Colorado Institute, said the lawsuit has constitutional grounds. She said the Colorado Constitution requires any changes to the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, known as TABOR, to be submitted to voters independently.

“You have to present this as a separate ballot measure,” Burton Brown said.

The complaint says Amendment 87 combined a constitutional change with a tax rate increase into a single issue. This harkens back to 2005, when voters considered Referendum C and Referendum D separately.

The lawsuit also challenges the state’s voter guide, known as the Blue Book. The complaint alleges that the guide’s tax tables were constructed on a calculation error and misreported the measure’s tax impact by up to $1.2 billion.

“Two of these tables contained incredibly misleading and, in fact, false information,” Burton Brown said.

Burton Brown also said voters were told the new revenue would fund areas such as education, but Polis has since said it would go toward Medicaid costs by the third year. She said higher taxes on businesses and high earners would be passed on to consumers and middle-class families.

Democrats push back

Shad Murib, chairman of the Colorado Democratic Party, said he expects the lawsuit to fail and called it a misuse of money.

“I think it’s stupid,” Murib said.

Murib said the change would benefit most Coloradans. He said 97 percent of residents would benefit from a tax cut.

“It’s a great opportunity for people to be able to just have a little extra money in their back pocket, and also for the state to invest in making Colorado an even better place to live,” Murib said.

Voters speak out

Bruce Polkowsky, who has lived in Colorado for 29 years, said he voted for Amendment 87 after thinking about it.

He said he considered a graduated tax fairer than a flat rate, but he was concerned that the measure did not provide enough detail on how the state would spend the money.

“I would like to see the lawsuit dismissed and the rule go into effect,” Polkowsky said.

Ranier Lopez, who has lived in Colorado for eight years, said he questions the motives of the people behind the lawsuit.

“It looks like they’re trying to protect themselves from people,” Lopez said.

Burton Brown said any taxpayer can file a lawsuit against a tax measure in Colorado and that senators defend taxpayers who voted against it.

“I just think part of the lawsuit is holding the state accountable,” Burton Brown said.

The senators also say the state’s official voting guide, known as the Blue Book, misled voters. The complaint says the state spent about $4 million to print it and mail it to Colorado households.

The lawsuit alleges that the guide’s tables were constructed on a methodological error. It says the state applied the new graduated rates to income already distributed in Colorado. Instead, the complaint says, the tax should first be calculated on a taxpayer’s total taxable income in Colorado, with the nonresident allocation applied next. The complaint cites Department of Revenue guidelines for this order of operations.

The senators say the difference is significant for high incomes. According to the complaint, the guide told taxpayers earning between $500,000 and $1 million would receive an average tax cut of $284. The senators say the correct calculation shows an average increase of about $2,651. They acknowledge that figure is approximate because the state’s spreadsheet does not disclose some data.

For that income bracket alone, the guide showed a tax reduction of $15.9 million, the complaint says. The senators estimate the actual increase at about $131 million for Colorado residents and up to $148 million for the entire bracket, including part-time residents and nonresidents who pay Colorado taxes.

The complaint alleges that nine of the 12 income brackets listed in the guide’s tax table were incorrect. It also says the state revenue estimate, which put the central forecast at $1.972 billion and the maximum at $2.7 billion, could be off by $1.2 billion.

Education and Medicaid Claims

The lawsuit also challenges how the guide describes where the money would go. It says the notice mentions education funding 12 times and child care funding five times, and states as fact that the measure would increase state funding available to school districts.

The complaint cites audio from a Nov. 12 Joint Budget Committee meeting, saying Polis told lawmakers the new revenue would not go to education, health improvements or early childhood, and that within three years it would all go to Medicaid.

What senators want

The senators ask the court to declare that Amendment 87 violates TABOR on both grounds, to enjoin the Department of Revenue from collecting any tax increases under the measure, and to award attorneys’ fees and costs.

The tax changes approved by Amendment 87 are expected to take effect on January 1.

Coloradans make a difference | Denver7 featured videos


Denver7 is committed to making a difference in our community by standing up for what’s right, listening, lending a hand, and keeping our promises. See this work in action in the videos above.

Gn usa

Logo