Vitamin D, fiber and flavor: are mushrooms healthy? | Well actually

Mr.Mushrooms are not as popular in the United States as they are in other parts of the world. On average, Americans eat just under 4 pounds (1.81 kg) of mushrooms per capita each year, while in South Korea, people eat nearly 6 pounds (2.72 kg) per year, and in Japan, that figure is closer to 12 pounds (5.44 kg).

Americans also don’t eat as wide a variety of mushrooms as other parts of the world, says Dr. Krystle Zuniga, a certified oncology dietitian based in Austin, Texas. “I often think of them as a forgotten vegetable,” she says, although she clarifies that they are technically mushrooms.

However, there are good reasons to increase our consumption of mushrooms and incorporate different varieties into our diet. Here’s what experts say about the health benefits of mushrooms.

Are mushrooms healthy?

“For many years, the selling points of mushrooms were that they tasted good and had nothing bad in them,” says Dr. Robert Beelman, professor emeritus of food sciences and director of the Center for Plant and Mushroom Foods for Health at Penn State University. “There’s very little fat, no sugar, very few calories.”

The savory, umami flavor of mushrooms also makes them a particularly good option for anyone looking to eat less meat. “I often recommend replacing up to 50 percent of the ground meat with chopped mushrooms for meatball, taco, or meat sauce recipes,” says Marisa Moore, a registered nutritionist based in Atlanta.

Unlike meat, mushrooms are not a solid source of protein. But they provide a healthy mix of different types of fiber, including beta-glucans, a kind of soluble fiber also found in oats and barley, which “have been shown to help lower cholesterol levels,” says Moore, and chitin, an insoluble fiber that supports good bacteria in the gut. Beta-glucans have a particularly interesting composition that the human body recognizes as “something a little foreign,” Zuniga notes, “that can help stimulate and activate the immune system.” In studies, beta-glucans have shown promising anti-inflammatory effects.

It is becoming easier and easier to buy a wide variety of mushrooms, especially from specialty grocers. While different varieties contain vitamins and minerals in slightly different concentrations, most mushrooms contain healthy compounds including potassium, which helps regulate blood pressure; selenium, which supports thyroid health; and B vitamins, which play many important roles, for example in cellular function and metabolism.

Why are mushrooms associated with vitamin D?

In addition to fortified milk and fatty fish, “mushrooms are one of the few sources of vitamin D that we can easily get into our diet,” Moore adds. “Vitamin D is essential for bone health, helps regulate the immune system, and plays an important role in regulating our mood and sleep.”

Yet vitamin D deficiency is considered widespread in the United States, particularly in winter, when our bodies naturally produce less due to sun exposure. Some mushrooms have even been treated with UV light, which converts a compound called ergosterol into vitamin D.

The average person needs about 15 micrograms of vitamin D per day, and while you’ll need to eat an impractical amount of mushrooms to reach that threshold, about a cup of those UV-treated mushrooms or wild mushrooms exposed to sunlight will get you there most of the time (and a cup of mushrooms cooks considerably).

“Mushrooms are the only thing in the produce aisle that can actually increase their vitamin D content just by being exposed to sunlight,” says Moore. In fact, you can increase the vitamin D in mushrooms yourself by placing the mushrooms, gills side up, in direct midday sunlight for 15 minutes to an hour, after which the vitamin D benefits appear to level off and then diminish, according to research.

ignore past newsletter promotion


Do mushrooms reduce cancer risk?

Some studies have found a correlation between higher overall mushroom consumption and a lower incidence of certain cancers, including breast cancer. But more research is needed to determine whether and why they have an effect on cancer risk.

It’s very difficult to isolate the effects of a specific food in this type of observational research, Zuniga says. “Someone who eats mushrooms probably also eats other fruits and vegetables.”

Part of the cancer prevention recommendations for all cancers is to eat a diet rich in plant foods, which confer the benefits of a range of nutrients and phytochemicals, she says. “Mushrooms are a food you can consider as part of our general recommendation to eat more plant foods to reduce your cancer risk,” says Zuniga. Some researchers believe that beta-glucans may increase the activity of the immune system in ways that improve the body’s recognition of and response to cancer cells.

Mushrooms also contain unique compounds “with high antioxidant capacity,” meaning they fight cellular damage that causes many health problems, Zuniga says.

For example, mushrooms are the most important dietary source of an antioxidant called ergothioneine, which could play a role in “potentially controlling or preventing chronic diseases, particularly neurodegenerative diseases,” says Beelman. Some researchers have observed a link between lower blood levels of ergothioneine and a higher risk of cognitive impairment, neurodegenerative diseases, cardiovascular disease, frailty, and all-cause mortality. These researchers consider ergothioneine a “promising nutritional intervention” to support cognitive resilience, although long-term trials proving a direct causal relationship are lacking. Beelman suggests aiming for 10 mg of ergothioneine per day, or about one cup of oyster mushrooms. Lion’s mane, porcini and shiitake varieties are also good sources.

Mushroom supplements are widely available. But Zuniga warns that in the United States, “because of poor regulation of dietary supplements,” one cannot be sure what is in them. Some mushroom supplements may be approved, but Moore generally recommends “starting with whole foods whenever possible.”

“You’re bound to find a mushroom you like,” adds Zuniga. “There is such a variety of choices.”

Gn Health

Logo