Why an SNL comedy skit about guarding went viral: NPR

The SNL commercial parody “Sister” hit out at girls who take care of their parents without help from their brothers. NPR’s Juana Summers speaks with writer Liz Plank about her Substack essay explaining why it resonated.




Transcription

JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:

Sometimes comedy hits a little too close to home. A skit from this weekend’s “Saturday Night Live” show hosted by John Mulaney is going viral. Here’s the setup: a fake ad for this amazing new service to help men care for their aging parents.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, “SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE”)

JOHN MULANEY: (As character) That’s when I heard about Sister.

(LAUGH)

MULANEY: Sister is a 24/7 in-home senior care provider, completely free, and so is your sister. Now I don’t have to worry about Dad getting the care and attention he needs because my sister will.

SUMMERS: And that sketch resonated with many viewers. Liz Plank wrote an essay about this for her Substack. It’s called “The Sister Sketch is a documentary.” Plank is a writer and host of the podcast “Boy Problems,” and she joins me now. Welcome to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED.

LIZ PLANK: Thanks for having me.

SUMMERS: I mean, Liz, I just have to say that my group text messages have been through the roof. A friend even called me about this skit and said if you haven’t watched it, you need to go see it now. Here is a link. What was your first reaction when you saw this sketch?

PLANK: I had the same experience. I mean, it exploded in every group chat I had with women, just sharing a lot of laughter, but also a lot of heartbreak. I think a lot of women…

SUMMERS: Yeah.

PLANK: …We were both triggered and we felt equally empowered to send it to their group chat, to their family group chat. I mean, that’s what I ended up doing for a lot of my friends who I know had problems with their brothers, with their boyfriends, right? – men in their lives who aren’t doing their fair share. And so it was kind of – a pretty exciting time, to be honest (laughs).

SUMMERS: I have to say, when I watched it, it was kind of this weird cocktail. It was like a mixture of I thought it was funny, but I was also frustrated. It brought out a resentment I didn’t expect to feel. Was there anything specific about the sketch that you think made it resonate so much?

PLANK: I think what gave you this – what you’re describing is this feeling, yes, both seen but also frustrated. You know, I think as a feminist and, you know, I know women in general, we’ve been – a lot of us have tried to have these conversations with the men in our lives. You know, we tried to explain it, to send them articles, to send them studies, to talk about the second day’s work, to talk about…

SUMMERS: Yeah.

PLANK: …You know, the emotional toll that it can take. And we’ve tried a million ways to have these conversations, and it hasn’t always been well received. And so I think one of the things that you bring up, that kind of frustration, it was almost this feeling of good, for men to know that this is happening.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, “SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE”)

ANDREW DISMUKES: (As character) I love my mother more than anything. This doesn’t mean I want to help him go to the bathroom. Neither will my sister, but she will.

PLANK: The men know we take on all this work, but they still don’t do anything.

SUMMERS: I mean, basically, the premise of the sketch is really simple. For example, why pay for expensive elder care when you can just text your sister? And I want to note here that, according to a recent report from AARP and the National Alliance for Caregiving, 3 out of 5 family caregivers are women, and this is unpaid work.

PLANK: Yes, not only is it unpaid, but it prevents women from accumulating wealth, and, you know, getting promotions at work because they’re taking this unpaid work. And, you know, one of the things I thought about and commented on on the SNL video was – now do the woman’s version.

SUMMERS: You know, Liz, I have to say that I’m an only child. I’m not a sister per se, but I know what it means to have the experience of being a person helping to seek high-quality care for an older adult. And honestly, it’s really hard. It’s frustrating. It’s never-ending and it’s something that can have profound impacts on your relationships and, over time, create resentment, not only towards the parent or elderly person who needs this care, but also towards other people around you who are in a relationship with that person, who are supposed to be involved. Can you talk a little more about that aspect and what the sketch exposes?

PLANK: Yes, I… women are taking on all these responsibilities, and they’re very frustrated. And to answer your point, they have a lot of resentment, and it affects our relationships. You know, our relationships are only as good as the person who is most unhappy in that relationship, right?

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, “SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE”)

BEN MARSHALL: (As my sister’s husband) I just don’t see why we have to turn our lives upside down.

JANE WICKLINE: (as sister, shouting) Because he’s my father – that’s why.

MARSHALL: (as sister’s husband) OK.

PLANK: If the brother is fine and has no problems, but the sister feels all this frustration, it’s going to affect our relationship. You know, patriarchy impacts our relationships.

SUMMERS: We’ve talked a lot about how this has affected so many women in both of our lives, but I wonder: What are you hearing from the men in your life about this sketch?

PLANK: Not much to be honest.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, “SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE”)

KENAN THOMPSON: (As character) I was overwhelmed by my father’s medication, not my sister. She doesn’t let this kind of thing faze her at all. Or if she does, she hasn’t told me about it because I haven’t asked.

PLANK: I hope men receive that and see themselves in this sketch. But like many criticisms that can come from women, many men think it’s not about them. But I… yeah, I don’t see enough men talking about it. I mean, this… I’m just going to tell the truth. On that, you know, I hope to see more men leading these conversations, but, you know, we’re two women talking about it now. And I’d like to see more men do it.

SUMMERS: Before I let you go, Liz, I have to ask you about the ending of that sketch because it stuck with me. There is a disclaimer at the end of this kind of false advertising, and it states that the offer on Sister is void if she has a good therapist. I wonder how you reacted to that.

PLANK: I didn’t like it. I’ll be honest. I think this is another way of blaming women for a problem they didn’t cause. And that’s kind of why we’re here, right? And the idea that – obviously, I would love – I mean, again, if we had maybe had a different president or a sister as president, we would have a lot more access to mental health services, which everyone should have access to but unfortunately aren’t accessible in 2026. And so that suggests that, yes, sisters of a certain class are able to avoid this sort of patriarchal programming, you know, when that’s just not true. You know, I – what I would have – if I could have written the sketch, I would have actually said, this doesn’t apply to sisters whose brothers are in therapy or have a therapist. I think it’s men who need to solve this problem. They are not women.

SUMMERS: Writer Liz Plank – you can read her newsletter, Airplane Fashion on Substack. Liz, thank you very much.

BOARD: Thank you very much.

(SOUNDBITE OF ZIPS SONG, “HEARTLESS”)

Copyright © 2026 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit the terms of use and permissions pages on our website at www.npr.org for more information.

The accuracy and availability of transcripts for NPR programming may vary. The text of the transcript may also be edited to correct errors or match audio updates. Audio may be edited after its original broadcast or publication. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio recording.

Please note that NPR platforms and products also include certain programming produced by third parties; NPR cannot guarantee transcriptions of this content and some transcriptions may be produced using automated or other tools.

Gn entert

Logo