Why gold prices are falling

Léonhard Foeger | Reuters

Investors in precious metals can be forgiven if they feel like the past year has given them a boost.

After a torrid period, which saw the price of gold reach new records 53 times in 2025, gold hit an all-time high of $5,589.38 per ounce on January 28, only to experience an almost equally historic drop. On Wednesday, gold fell below $3,800 for the first time since September 2025, about a third below its peak.

A convergence of factors pushed gold to all-time highs earlier this year, according to Suki Cooper, global head of commodities research at Standard Chartered, the London-based multinational bank. Today, a different convergence is driving prices down.

“Gold can behave like a commodity or a currency,” Cooper said.

The role it plays depends on the factors dominating the market and the psyche of investors, and at present it is the monetary argument that is driving the precious metal lower.

Cooper said gold’s rise began with strong physical demand that began in 2022 and raised the floor under prices. A second phase followed, as investors rethought the place of gold in their portfolios. With the cost of holding a non-yielding asset falling, they began to think about the metal for the longer term. That, Cooper said, marked a turnaround.

Until early 2025, Cooper said, long-term investors, particularly those in gold-backed exchange-traded funds, had reduced their exposure, which effectively increased supply in the market. Last year, the situation reversed: ETF holdings, led by SPDR Gold shares (GLD), increased by around 800 tonnes and helped absorb excess market supply.

“There was a lot of one-way interest, a lot of appetite to buy but not to sell,” Cooper said.

As secondary market sales remained subdued, prices continued to rise. At the end of 2025, ETF net assets exceeded 4,000 tonnes. Globally, gold ETFs had their strongest year in terms of inflows, $89 billion, led by North America, according to the World Gold Council, with assets more than doubling to $559 billion in total.

Stock chart iconStock chart icon

hide content

SPDR Gold Shares ETF in 2026.

A weaker dollarFalling bond yields and concerns about global debt “are laying the groundwork for gold to hit record highs in 2026,” Cooper said.

Investors who had been underexposed to the metal continued to buy.

Evan Mills, a financial advisor at Scholar Financial Advising, a fee-based firm based in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, said falling interest rates, expectations of further rate cuts and a weakening dollar were all reasons investors favored gold.

“It was a great place if you were an investor in gold and commodities as a whole,” Mills said. And investors have done extremely well, especially with lower interest rates. “Cash doesn’t work well in this environment, so a lot of people are looking to other places to conserve cash and maintain purchasing power,” Mills said.

This changed after January.

The speed of the recovery has worried some investors and there has been growing talk of possible Fed tightening. Then, Cooper noted, conflict in the Middle East erupted and gold changed roles. It ceased to serve as a safe haven for portfolios and became “a liquidity provider”.

Cooper explained that because it was liquid and easy to sell, investors sold it to raise cash, which triggered the first correction. Since then, she said, markets have been pricing in the Fed’s actions.

“In 2026, the Fed has moved more toward higher interest rates,” Mills said.

This week, Christopher Waller, a member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, said a 50 basis point rate hike might be necessary to “shock people.”

“There are higher Treasury yields and a stronger dollar, so the opportunity cost of holding an asset that doesn’t produce income is much higher,” Mills said.

Fed Governor Waller: We need to be a little more aggressive in our rate hikes to control inflation

Mills said that in the current situation, gold investors are not benefiting from an environment where liquidity is actually doing well, with money market funds potentially yielding 4-5%.

“Cash maintains purchasing power, and you don’t need to put it in an asset that is illiquid or where you’re relying on another person to see the value,” Mills said.

From 2025 to 2026, gold has not become less rare; alternatives to ownership have become more attractive.

“Stocks, bonds, classic portfolio composition all became much more attractive, so people looked at the opportunity cost and decided it was no longer worth holding gold,” Mills said.

This was also the case for other metals in 2026, with money in free fall from a record price.

Why Investors Should Be Cautious About Gold

After an extraordinary rally, it’s easy to start questioning gold. Mills said investors should start by remembering that expectations were extremely high. “When the expectations are 20 or 30 percent returns a year, then of course when yields fall, people start to panic,” Mills said.

Panic should not be the watchword for gold investors, but caution must remain.

“In the short term, with real yields rising and the dollar likely strengthening with future Fed hikes, I would be cautious about gold across the portfolio,” Mills said.

The key for investors is to understand why gold is in your portfolio.

“If you’re looking for a short-term buy, then gold probably doesn’t belong in your portfolio,” Mills said. If the metal is considered a hedge, gold can still be a valuable part of a portfolio, but it can still be a poor investment depending on the price you pay for access to it.

“If you’re looking at gold as a growth item in your portfolio, you’ll probably be disappointed,” he said. “Gold is insurance, not an engine, and the mistake is to take out insurance when its price has skyrocketed,” he added.

For investors who bought at the January high as a modest long-term hedge, a sharp downturn doesn’t defeat their purpose, he said. “You really have no reason to worry, because that’s what gold is all about.”

Gold tends to do well when the dollar weakens or when markets and geopolitics become uncertain, Mills said, and when those pressures subside, the rest of the portfolio should pick up the slack.

“That’s the whole point of insurance and the whole point of diversification,” he said. “Gold does well when other parts of your portfolio are in danger of softening, and when they turn around, that’s a good thing.”

Stock chart iconStock chart icon

hide content

Long-term gold price performance.

Other commodity experts say gold remains a good long-term bet. Amy Gower, head of metals and mining strategy at Morgan Stanley, told CNBC’s “Squawk Box Europe” that there are “still plenty of reasons” for investors to hold onto their gold despite this year’s correction.

Philip Diehl, former director of the U.S. Mint and now president of U.S. Money Reserve, an Austin, Texas-based distributor of government-issued gold, silver and platinum coins, said the long-term case for gold is still in place, but the combination of abrupt changes in U.S. trade policy and geopolitical alliances, as well as the war in Iran, is considered a black swan event for the precious metal.

“The fundamentals that drove this bull market remain in place. They were interrupted by the Category 5 hurricane that ripped through the Persian Gulf during reckless war,” Diehl said.

He hopes that will change after American voters “issued a mandate” to end this war two weeks ago.

“I am confident that gold prices will return to their upward trajectory in 2027, as oil prices normalize and pump prices fall, allowing interest rates to stabilize,” Diehl said.

Gold tests new lows as retail trade burns and central bank purchases diverge

Central banks continue to buy gold, with the highest monthly total recorded in September, according to the World Gold Council, although overall purchases are 7% lower than the same period last year.

Marc Chandler, managing partner and chief market strategist at Bannockburn Capital Markets, said surveys suggest that, overall, this will not change. “However, don’t just think about China or U.S. rivals,” Chandler said, noting that the World Gold Council has identified NATO member Poland as one of the biggest buyers for most of this year.

“Retail has been burned,” Chandler said. “Rising interest rates have made non-interest-bearing assets less attractive, including bitcoin.”

Chandler said the price of gold was heading toward $3,500 to $3,600. Gold hit a new low below $3,700 on Thursday morning.

“There’s nothing on the charts that indicates a low is in place,” Chandler said. “For anxious pickers, I urge caution and patience to see a trend toward a reversal. For the most part, the decline appears fairly orderly.”

“Gold remains very expensive relative to all but the last two years,” Chandler said, noting that gold’s 10-year (120-month) moving average is about $2,127 and its 20-year (240-month) moving average is about $1,666.

Markets are starting to wake up to the “revenge of the old economy,” says oil expert

Gn bussni

Logo