Updated November 21, 2026, 4:44 p.m. ET
Ohio State just hasn’t been the same since a 19-15 win over Indiana on Oct. 17, as Curt Cignetti was quick to point out this week: “We tore the heart out of this team,” he said. “They haven’t been the same since, without the quarterback.”
The calculations are verified. Winners of five of six heading into the game in Bloomington, the No. 17 Buckeyes have lost three of four since beating the No. 5 Hoosiers but lost Julian Sayin to a season-ending injury. The latest loss, 31-28 to Nebraska, eliminates Ohio State from the College Football Playoff race.
Nebraska’s victory shouldn’t come with an asterisk. The Cornhuskers finally took down an elite opponent in the fourth quarter, ending a 31-game winless streak against ranked competition and at least partially offsetting earlier collapses against Indiana, No. 14 Oregon and Washington. There was nothing cheap about this victory.
And Cignetti’s view has a flaw. This isn’t even the first time in the past 365 days that Ohio State has dropped three of four; they also lost three times in four games from last year’s Big Ten championship game to September’s nonconference loss at No. 8 Texas. Before that, OSU hadn’t gone 1-3 in a four-game span since the end of the 2013 through the start of the 2014 seasons.
Officially sending the Buckeyes to a non-playoff postseason destination and ending their chance at the Big Ten championship, this latest result should trigger several uncomfortable questions about the state of the program at Ohio State and put coach Ryan Day in familiar territory — on the hot seat and needing to turn things around as soon as possible.
It’ll be a long week until taking on rival Michigan. There will be an even longer offseason for the Buckeyes, full of personnel and coaching changes that could resemble something close to a reboot before taking the field again next September.
Looking ahead, the quarterback situation is not good. Sayin could return after recovering from an injury, or he could capitalize on his performance since taking over before last season and enter the NFL Draft. Given the uncertainty in the portal era, Sayin could also evaluate its Power Four market and play elsewhere in 2027.
His obvious replacement is not on the list. It won’t be former five-star recruit Tavien St. Clair, who clearly isn’t on Day’s radar after failing to climb the depth chart in Sayin’s absence. It may not be freshman Luke Fahey, who has been predictably uneven since being thrust into the lineup.
Either way, next year’s starter won’t be thrown to Jeremiah Smith. The Heisman Trophy favorite passed for 165 yards and caught both scores from Fahey, once again doing almost all the damage for an offense that would be even more lost in the wilderness without his ability to take over games. He became the first player in Big Ten history with 4,000 receiving yards.
There will also be coaching changes. Day went with two former NFL head coaches in his last two major moves, bringing in Matt Patricia to run the defense and Arthur Smith for the offense. Hiring Patricia paid off. although his unit has allowed a combined 61 points in defeat in the last two road games. It’s harder to evaluate Smith’s first season given Sayin’s absence.
So Day might make another change at offensive coordinator. He’ll almost certainly reorganize the rest of his team, continuing a process that began this month with this month’s firing of first-year special teams coordinator Robby Discher after a collapse against Oregon.
He doesn’t really have a choice. This is the second time in three years that Day has been put under the microscope. Last time out, in 2024, he avoided another loss to Michigan by leading the Buckeyes to the national championship in the inaugural 12-team tournament. This time, OSU won’t be able to play Day in the hot seat — not when the playoff destination is the Citrus Bowl instead of the postseason.
Gn headline
