Chuck Schumer vs. Chris Van Hollen: The real issue in the fight against the Senate leader

Sen. Chuck Schumer has led the Senate Democratic caucus for 10 years, and he now faces the most serious challenge he’s ever faced for his position.

With Democrats poised to secure their largest majority since the start of Barack Obama’s presidency, Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen is challenging Schumer for the role of leader of this new majority. Van Hollen has gained support from several senators so far, as well as various outside progressive groups.

In one sense, the reasons Democrats might want to abandon Schumer are obvious. Schumer is 75 years old and not a particularly charismatic messenger or compelling speaker. His personal positions on issues such as U.S. support for Israel and his long-standing relationship with Wall Street and corporate donors put him out of step with the Democratic base. And polls consistently show him to be extremely unpopular.

At the same time, the Senate majority leader’s job isn’t about winning a national popularity contest, either. It’s about running the Senate – a difficult mission that involves a multitude of tasks, including, but not limited to, setting the legislative calendar, developing overall legislative and policy strategy, negotiating with outside interest groups, coordinating with the Speaker of the House and the President, and trying to hold a majority in the next election.

And there’s another underrated part of the job: volunteering to be the only political figure who most likely to be hated. Many leaders seen as particularly effective in their roles – from Mitch McConnell to Nancy Pelosi – have been consistently unpopular, often because their positions required constantly facing attacks from outside and within their party.

It’s the latter that’s perhaps the least discussed — and in conversations with legislative branch veterans from across the political spectrum, I’ve been surprised how often it’s brought up as a critical element of choosing one or the other.

The “heat shield” function of the leader of the senatorial majority

Chuck Schumer and Mitch McConnell talk heads down in a busy hallway.

Chuck Schumer and Mitch McConnell speak at the Capitol in February 2024.
Craig Hudson/Bloomberg via Getty Images

How would Van Hollen do the job differently? Publicly, he addressed a few points.

In first announcing his leadership bid last week, Van Hollen told MS NOW’s Jen Psaki that Democrats should end President Donald Trump’s “illegal and senseless” war in Iran this year, giving Trump a choice: end the war, or the government is shut down.

He told a conference in Denver that he opposed the Senate filibuster — the rule that requires 60 votes to advance almost all legislation — and said he should “talk to the caucus about it.”

And asked by NPR’s Steve Inskeep to name a specific issue on which his approach would differ from Schumer’s, Van Hollen said he would hold a floor vote on the PRO Act, a labor rights bill.

These three positions seem to suggest that Van Hollen would attempt to steer what will be a 56-member Senate caucus in a more progressive direction.

But some experts were skeptical about the effectiveness of this solution.

“A leader is like a middleman,” James Wallner, a former Senate Republican aide, told me. “They have to negotiate with everyone. In the Senate, we haven’t really seen leaders from one wing of the party. They are generally moderate in their disposition – and that puts them in a position to negotiate with their own colleagues.”

Indeed, former and current Senate leadership collaborators described the work quite differently: it is less about pushing the caucus to do what we want than about channeling what senators already want to do, reaching consensus among them and responding to their needs.

Justin Goodman, a former Schumer aide, told me that a crucial part of the job was being “a heat shield for members when tough decisions need to be made, and those are tough decisions that the caucus has support for.”

The premise here is that much, and perhaps most, of what the Democratic base wants cannot happen. Whether it’s because of Trump’s veto, House rules, or simply because many Democratic senators don’t want it to happen — the idea is that many disappointments are inevitable and the leader will be the one to take responsibility. (Another commonly used term? A “sin eater.”)

Take, for example, the PRO Act — which, in 2021 and 2022, the last time Democrats controlled Washington, Schumer effectively refused to bring it to a floor vote. According to Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Schumer told him he wouldn’t do it unless Sanders could already muster the 60 supporters needed to defeat the filibuster.

The implication is that, if the bill was certain to fail anyway, Schumer didn’t want to force his vulnerable members to vote that might be uncomfortable for them — which would expose them to either rank-and-file fury or attack ads for the general election.

Van Hollen’s stated desire to hold a vote for the PRO Act would signal a different approach — one that would make progressives happy and force some moderates to vote uncomfortably.

It is not clear that this approach would be more effective in ensuring that progressive priorities are actually enshrined in law. (And the last time Schumer was majority leader, he in some cases put moderates on the spot — like in his push to change Senate rules to pass a voting rights bill, which Senators Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema voted against.)

But Schumer’s most famous example of “eating sin” occurred in March 2025, when he helped orchestrate passage of a government funding bill, despite progressives’ desire to threaten a shutdown in hopes of combating what they saw as the authoritarian abuses of the new Trump administration. “I so believe I did the right thing,” Schumer said then.

“No one wants the government to close. But a lot of people don’t want to be the ones to vote ‘yes’ to keep it open,” Goodman told me. “So Senator Schumer, as a leader, was often the one doing the work and taking the pressure for it.”

Schumer then endorsed a more confrontational strategy that resulted in a 43-day government shutdown that fall — but even though Democrats were seen as having won the political victory in that fight, some of their members became increasingly concerned about the pain caused by government benefit disruptions.

Eventually, some Democrats opted out and voted with the Republican Party to reopen the government — and although Schumer officially opposed that reopening, he was still criticized for not doing enough to stop it.

Has Schumer lost too much credibility to sell these compromises to the base?

Chuck Schumer is seen from below, with several microphones in his face and the white columns of the Capitol behind him.

Schumer speaks to reporters outside the United States Capitol in Washington, DC on November 18, 2026.
Brendan Smialowski/AFP via Getty Images

That said, just because Schumer has taken on the role of “sin eater” in the past doesn’t mean he’s the only one who can do so in the future. It’s possible that someone more in touch with the party’s base would be better able to find consensus.

Van Hollen is backed by several of the most progressive senators and senators-elect — including Sanders, Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota — but he and his supporters have also pushed back against attempts to portray this contest as simply a showdown between progressives and moderates.

Indeed, when I spoke to Ezra Levin, co-founder of the progressive group Indivisible, he made a rather different argument. Levin argued that in reality, Van Hollen would make a better It’s about selling the compromises that will inevitably have to be made to the grassroots – including to progressives like him.

Levin said he completely agreed that part of the next leader’s job would be to get the caucus to “do some things that are going to be very unpopular” — including funding the government and raising the debt ceiling. “Senate Majority Leader Chris Van Hollen, if he does his job properly, is going to annoy me and other people a lot,” Levin said.

But, he continued, because of Schumer’s history and the base’s long-standing lack of trust, Schumer will simply have a harder time getting these compromises accepted.

“If the Senate majority leader is a sponge for anger, you have to change that sponge more than once a decade,” Levin said. “Or this sponge will cease to be useful.”

Indeed, House Republicans have twice experienced a dynamic like this, where the base’s deep distrust of Speakers John Boehner and Kevin McCarthy resulted in Boehner’s resignation and McCarthy’s ouster. Then their more conservative successors, Paul Ryan and Mike Johnson, proposed similar legislative compromises without encountering serious revolt. Having a new face can really buy some goodwill and ease worries, for a while.

“If I’m a moderate in the Senate, I want someone else to take the blame if we have to pass something,” Levin said. “Who can absorb this blame? Who has credibility with outside actors? With the grassroots groups that blow up my phone? With all components of the Democratic Party?”

Gn usa

Logo