Republicans are losing hope in Reconciliation 3.0

  • “What concerns me is that we’re wasting the few days we have left on something that’s not going to get out of the House,” outgoing House Budget Chairman Jodey Arrington (R-Texas) told Axios of the Senate’s emerging plan.
  • Republicans have already passed two reconciliation bills in Congress: the “big, beautiful bill” in the summer of 2025, and nearly $70 billion for immigration control in the summer of 2026.

Zoom: Finding spending offsets could reopen some of the most contentious fights in the Republican Party’s first reconciliation agenda.

  • Arrington told Axios that Senate Republicans are concerned that making savings in health care spending could open the door to amendment votes that reverse Medicaid cuts. in the One Big, Beautiful Bill Act.
  • But Arrington, who did not seek re-election in 2026, told Axios he doesn’t believe the Senate proposal has the votes needed to pass the House without offsets.

State of play: Arrington said he raised his concerns with Senate Budget Chairman Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) and argued that Republicans should not let the risks deter them from pursuing additional spending cuts.

  • “Some Republican members of the Senate might go rogue and decide, I don’t know, to repeal some of the reforms that we introduced in the ‘big, beautiful bill.’ Maybe they’re doing it out of spite for President Trump,” he said.
  • “We’re past the midterm elections. We lost, but we still have this window to do what we think is right,” he said.

Between the lines: Senate Republicans have not committed to moving forward with another reconciliation package.

  • Emerging from a Wednesday night meeting on reconciliation, Sen. Johnson told reporters that the Senate would “probably” not move forward this week, but that a reconciliation bill was not “off the table.”
  • Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) told reporters he wanted to consider working with Democrats on funding, but that reconciliation remained an “option” Wednesday evening.

What they say: “It has to have some offsets,” Rep. Andrew Clyde (R-Ga.), a member of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, told Axios.

  • Rep. Eli Crane (R-Ariz.), another HFC member, also expressed skepticism about the proposal and its chances of passage. “It’s not that I don’t want to fund the Department of Defense, but it’s always, ‘Hey, are we just going to add this to the debt, add that to the deficit,'” he told Axios.

The plot: Even if the two chambers manage to reach an agreement, House Republican leaders have difficulty convincing their own members to show up for votes.

  • GOP leaders were forced to take a vote on procedural rules Wednesday after 14 Republicans failed to show up, leaving leaders without the votes needed to move forward.
  • Rep. Dan Meuser (R-Pa.) told Axios that his colleagues are expected to return to Washington: “I mean, they’ll be paid until January 3.”

What’s next: The House leaves Thursday for the Thanksgiving holiday.

Gn headline

Logo