Data shows the CFP committee is strengthening the SEC more than ever, and it’s not close

Shane Beamer didn’t watch the College Football Playoff standings Tuesday night, so when he came home late, his son had to break the news.

South Carolina was still ranked.

The Gamecocks had been crushed 34-6 at Arkansas three days earlier, beaten by a one-win SEC team that knocked them out of the AP Top 25. The CFP selection committee did not follow suit, causing them to slide from #17 to #21.

“I appreciate that the committee, you know, feels that way about us,” Beamer said Wednesday during the SEC coaches’ weekly teleconference. “I appreciate that the committee respects what it means to participate in this conference.”

This feeling is truer today than ever, Shane. It took pushing for a nine-game SEC slate and urging the CFP committee to weigh a crucial metric: the strength of the conference’s improvement.

The playoffs indicate that this is not a new metric, but simply an existing metric presented with “a greater emphasis on differences in strength of schedule within the same conference.”

This means that two teams in the same league with the same record do not necessarily have comparable CVs. But does this turn out to be true?

The SEC has pushed for “improvement,” starting when the SEC voted in August 2025 to add a ninth conference game. Commissioner Greg Sankey said the committee’s new scheduling tools favored the decision.

In November of last year, his coaches didn’t believe it.

“We were all promised that a measure of the strength of the schedule would be taken into account,” Eli Drinkwitz of Missouri said then. “That didn’t happen.”

Turns out Sankey was right. The league simply had to wait for the move to a ninth conference game this fall. The pendulum has swung dramatically in the SEC, but is the CFP committee giving the league too much benefit of the doubt?

At the very least, the SEC has become the favorite son of the PSC. Add up how much the committee placed each league’s teams above or below the AP poll in the top three rankings and the SEC gets an incredible 41-spot lead, its largest advantage since the rankings began in 2014.

The committee is moving further away from voters in favor of the SEC than ever before. The previous high was 34 places in 2018.

This change in favor of the SEC marks a dramatic turnaround from last year. Over the first three rankings of 2024 and 2025, the committee has consistently rated SEC programs overall lower than the AP survey in net rating. Last season, this figure was minus-10 over three weeks.

This year, Alabama alone accounts for 12 of those spots, four more than AP across all three versions. If you instead measure the CFP’s placement of SEC teams against the coaches’ poll, the conference is still ahead by 32 spots.

Naturally, this net benefit comes at a cost. By simple cause and effect, when the SEC gains influence, other teams inevitably fall.

Relative to their positions in the AP polls, the Big Ten and ACC fell to historically low rankings this season. The Big Ten is down five overall, its lowest mark ever by a hair, through three weeks. The ACC drops 11 spots in total.

The committee hasn’t placed a single ACC team above its AP spot all season. Independent Notre Dame wasn’t helped either, ranking a total of 12 spots below the AP, its lowest mark ever. Boise State ranked a total of 14 locations lower.

So, in a year where the SEC receives more favor than ever from the CFP, its main rival, the Big Ten, has never performed worse against the AP in the committee’s rankings. These are the same teams that are fighting two- or three-loss programs in the SEC for at-large bids.

How the CFP committee rankings differ from the AP Top 25 over three weeks

Conference/TeamHigher spotsLower spotsNetRanking in 13 CFP seasons
SECOND421+41Highest difference
Big 1268-29th highest
Big Ten1116-5The lowest
ACC011-11The lowest
Notre Dame012-12The lowest
Pac-12014-14The lowest

Sources: College Football Playoff, AP Top 25

But this is where the committee’s explanation fails. At no time has the PSC said outright that the SEC is stronger than it has ever been. Remember that “improvement” was sold as a way to sort teams within a conference, not to give one conference more favor over another. The Big Ten and Big 12 already played nine championship games, and neither has had such a result since the SEC moved to a nine-game schedule.

The tool designed to compare teams within the same league is here, and in the same season, SEC teams are outperforming all other teams outside the league.

The bottom of Tuesday’s standings reads like a copy and paste of the SEC standings. South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida and Ole Miss, which suffered four losses, are between 21st and 25th place. The four 6-4 teams ranked in the top 25 are the most ever ranked in the CFP rankings at this point in a season. The previous record was two – and those teams came from separate conferences.

In the top three rankings of the previous 12 seasons combined, the committee ranked five teams with four losses.

And don’t forget the effects on the Group of Six. Liberty is 9-1. Memphis is 8-2. The AP ranks both, but the committee ranks neither, instead opting for four SEC teams with four losses.

Rising tide

But again, this is not up to the SEC. What about “improvement” supposed to compare teams within the same league?

This brings us back to Alabama.

Tennessee smothered the Crimson Tide 26-10 at Neyland Stadium in October, limiting them to just 201 yards and forcing four turnovers. The two now hold identical records of 8-2. Many fans seem perturbed that Alabama is ranked higher than Tennessee, but the Tide’s resume is a bit better. The AP separates them in two places, which is doable. What’s crazy is that the committee ranks Alabama at No. 3 and Tennessee at No. 9, six spots apart.

Two teams in the same league with the same record and a head-to-head result that the committee cites among its fundamental principles, and yet a wide gulf separates them. This is where, theoretically, the new “improvement” comparing schedules within the conference is supposed to explain the Tide.

There are two problems: the PCP has not explained how improvement perceives both, and the public does not have access to this data.

“Basically, there are so many measures that it’s not really possible to make them public with an explanation about them right now,” CFP Executive Director Rich Clark said Tuesday. “That’s something we’re looking at. We’re looking at that in the offseason to see what metrics and how we would potentially present them in future seasons.”

President Hunter Yurachek compared the relative offenses and defenses of Alabama and Tennessee, and the Tide have a big offensive advantage but a top-5 defense that’s barely ahead of 6th-ranked Tennessee.

“Quite honestly, when we watch (Alabama) on film, when we watch their games, we really feel like they’re one of the top three or four teams in the country,” Yurachek said.

Ahh, the eye test. No mention of the improvement in conference strength, which should explain the gap. Well, theoretically. And it’s a problem that requires better explanation and more transparency from the PCP.

Non-conference boost

As for the SEC receiving more favor than the Big Ten and other power conferences, the season’s results at least provide some credibility.

“I’m sure everyone has seen the stat, I don’t know what it is, but it’s there,” Georgia coach Kirby Smart said Wednesday.

The SEC is 10-2 against non-conference opponents from power leagues and Notre Dame, its best mark to this point in any season in the CFP era. The Big Ten is 4-10, its worst in those same 13 seasons.

The biggest blow to the Big Ten was Texas’ fourth-quarter comeback against Ohio State in September.

That may argue for the best teams in the SEC, but it doesn’t argue for a 6-4 team over a 9-1 team, nor for a 16-point loser ranked six spots above the winner.

“We’ve played six ranked teams at this point in the season,” Texas A&M coach Mike Elko said. “And it’s a league that punishes you severely if you don’t do things right.”

Saturday means more.

Tuesday night never meant less than an SEC loss.

Gn sports

Logo