EDITOR’S NOTE: Warning: This story contains graphic descriptions of violence and references to self-harm and suicide.
A Florida man is on trial for kidnapping and killing a British woman last year after meeting her on the now-defunct Motherless.com, an extreme porn site that attracted international attention for hosting explicit sexual abuse and other content depicting gender-based violence.
Prosecutors in Marion County, Florida, say Dwain Hall, 54, killed Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music teacher from southern England, in October 2025, after treating her there for about two years before traveling to the United States. Hall has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping.
Exelby had a history of mental illness, according to his family, and had struggled with severe depression and suicidal thoughts, having twice attempted suicide, the court heard.
In her opening statement, Assistant Florida State’s Attorney Amy Berndt said Exelby was “still trying to find a substitute” for self-harm and that a group of men she found on Motherless provided her with an outlet.
“Sonia was communicating on Motherless with many different men. She was trying to find someone who would kill her. Her mental health was deteriorating. She wanted to die and she knew she couldn’t do it herself,” Berndt said.
“Unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men ready to kill Sonia in the most tortuous and vile ways possible. And they were sending her messages and describing how they were going to kill her.”
Hall, who used the alias Alpha Sadist on the site, as well as other usernames, took advantage of this vulnerability to experience “sadistic pleasure,” according to prosecutors.
They say he asked Exelby to pay $4,000 in cash to kill her.
Hall, who denies killing Exelby, told police he had been intimate with her.

Hall’s defense team said he was trying to help a woman who wanted to die.
In October 2025, Exelby flew to the United States, where Hall picked her up at Gainesville Regional Airport in Florida. From there, prosecutors say, he drove her to an Airbnb.
Prosecutors showed the court a text message Exelby allegedly sent to a friend during her time with Hall.
It read: “I’m sorry he keeps taking my phone, he doesn’t trust me. He made it clear there is no way out unless I shoot him. … No one will find me in time… I thought he would do it quickly and not give me time to think and (realize) that this is the last thing I will (say) to anyone if I don’t accept his offer to shoot him.”
Exelby’s body was found by police investigators on October 17, 2025, after Interpol contacted them about a woman reported missing to British police.
His body was found in a shallow grave, with four stab wounds and bruises.
This week, jurors saw a video recovered from Hall’s phone in which he ordered Exelby to repeat that she wanted to be beaten and to suffer.
“That’s how you wanted to die, right? You wanted to be beaten and made to suffer because you’re such a piece of shit? Say it,” Hall said in the video.
Prosecutors presented physical, digital and financial evidence linking Hall to Exelby’s death, including a purchased shovel and a knife that DNA testing showed had Exelby’s blood on it.
Investigators also found numerous images of other women being raped, tortured and murdered on Hall’s mobile phone, the court heard, including graphic and “horrific” photographs of sexual violence.
In court, Exelby’s sister Sara told jurors about Sonia’s difficult childhood and detailed her mental health struggles. But despite the personal challenges, Sara said her sister has always been supportive and kind.
“She felt like a burden, which she absolutely wasn’t, but she just had such a beautiful nature,” Sara said.
The trial, which began Tuesday, is expected to last at least a week.
The case has highlighted concerns about the role that some online platforms continue to play in the abuse of women, known as technology-facilitated violence against women and girls.
Motherless, which was at the center of a CNN investigation into a drug-facilitated online sexual assault earlier this year, was taken offline in May by Dutch authorities.
And in July, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton won a victory in blocking Motherless from operating under the .com registry.
