“I play Rocky” Fact and fiction: Butkus the dog and Stallone’s father

The beloved classic “Rocky” premiered a half-century ago this week. Five decades later, “I Play Rocky,” now in theaters, tells the story of how unknown writer and actor Sylvester Stallone fought his way to not only write the screenplay, but also play the iconic lead role of boxer Rocky Balboa, culminating in a Best Picture Oscar.

In 2026, is it really possible to go back in time and describe with perfect accuracy the making of “Rocky”? The unvarnished truth doesn’t always make for the best dramatic impact in a film – and Stallone and the filmmaking team have told somewhat different stories over the past 50 years.

“I Play Rocky” effectively walks the line between most events in the production with a certain degree of accuracy and improving others for the sake of more effective storytelling.

Here are some of the scenes that took place as “I Play Rocky” describes them – according to most participants – and a few others that use a fair amount of dramatic license.

Did Stallone really write “Rocky” in three days, then turn down hundreds of thousands to get a chance to star?

“I Play Rocky” shows Anthony Ippolito as Stallone walking into the office of Robert Chartoff and Irwin Winkler and playing hardball with big Hollywood producers, hearing offers of more and more money to give up his starring role until the producers finally agree. The need for careful storytelling, however, leaves out several details and makes Stallone seem even more completely unknown than he was at the time.

The real story was a bit more complicated and didn’t take into account the central role talent agents typically play in Hollywood deal negotiations. Chris Rumar, the son of one of Stallone’s first agents, Craig Rumar, said his father and Rumar’s partner agent, Larry Kubik, were instrumental in getting “Rocky” off the ground.

“Since my father died nine years ago, Mr. Stallone has been on a sort of tour about these inaccuracies about how ‘Rocky’ was put together,” Rumar said. Variety. “This time it was the triple whammy: We got ‘The Steps’ book, ‘I Play Rocky’ and the reissue of ‘Rocky,’ all in one month. He’s done interviews with some of the biggest names in media and no one challenges him.”

Kubik explained on the “Sexy Boomer” podcast that he and Rumar helped plant the seeds for “Rocky” by introducing Stallone to his friend, producer Gene Kirkwood, who had a deal with Chartoff and Winkler. Kirkwood and the agents first tried to put together Stallone’s “Hell’s Kitchen” script (which later became “Paradise Alley”), but Stallone had already sold it to another company and was trying to double down. So he returns home and begins working on another script, influenced by a boxing match he saw.

As seen in “I Play Rocky,” Stallone worked day and night for 72 hours to sketch out the basics of an aspiring boxer’s storyline, with his wife typing out his handwritten lines. But he didn’t write a complete screenplay that quickly: He sketched out the first third or so of the story, then made dozens of revisions before it was ready to shoot.

The neophyte actor insisted on starring in the film he wrote, an idea which seemed preposterous to the studio, which would have preferred James Caan, Nick Nolte or Ryan O’Neal. “We negotiated a deal and in the first deal he got paid for the script,” Kubik said. “United Artists told me that Mike Medavoy loved the script. But he loves it for Jimmy Caan. So I said, ‘That’s not going to happen.'”

As seen in “I Play Rocky,” United Artists reportedly offered up to $250,000 if Stallone would withdraw, but “Stallone held out.” Variety reported. Did he ever deliver the lead line “I play Rocky” to the producers when discussing who should star? It’s not clear if anyone remembers this.

Sylvester Stallone and Butkus in “Rocky”.

Getty Images

Did Stallone really sell his bull mastiff Butkus for $40 while he was broke, then buy him back?

In “I Play Rocky,” Stallone cherishes the stray dog ​​he found on the street during one of his darkest times. After moving to Los Angeles, he still struggles to make ends meet and unfortunately decides to sell Butkus to a stranger who compliments the dog for around $40. As Stallone often tells it and as seen in “I Play Rocky,” when it comes time to shoot “Rocky,” Stallone wants Butkus in the movie, so he tracks down the new owner, who says his kids love the dog, and ends up having to offer him thousands of dollars (the story ranges from $1,500 to $15,000) to buy him back.

Stallone has repeatedly told a version of Butkus’ story over the years, pointing to a man named “Little Jimmy” as the one who bought the dog while he was broke. Stallone implies that Little Jimmy was a stranger he met outside a 7-11, before selling the script for “Rocky.”

But Jimmy Gambina, a small-time boxing trainer who worked on “Rocky,” has a very different memory of what happened. Gambina told “Going the Distance” author Mike Sielski that he had kept the dog for Butkus during production of the film, and then Stallone gave the dog to Gambina after the birth of his son Sage because he saw how close they had become.

When it was time to film “Rocky II,” Stallone wanted the dog back so he could appear in the film. Gambina says he told Stallone, “Come and explain it to my son. If my son says it’s okay, I’ll let you take the dog back. But we’ve had the dog for three years now, and we love him.” Gambina says the two fell out sometime after Stallone insisted on taking the dog back.

Did Stallone break his knuckles on a frozen meat carcass at a Philadelphia meatpacking plant while filming?

Many people think that “Rocky” was filmed in Philadelphia. But only the iconic stairs, Rocky’s apartment and a few other exteriors were captured in the City of Brotherly Love during a frenetic five-day period. “I Play Rocky” shows Stallone’s Rocky Balboa training with sides of beef in a Philadelphia slaughterhouse, but the 1976 original was actually filmed at Shamrock Meats in the meat mecca of Vernon, just outside Los Angeles. However, the beef was frozen and after Stallone punched the frozen meat for eight hours straight, he ended up breaking a knuckle, making part of the movie accurate.

The rink where Rocky courts Adrian after hours was the Ice Capades chalet in Santa Monica, California, which later became a Fred Segal store, while the climactic boxing match was filmed at the Olympic Auditorium and the LA Sports Arena.

“To help keep the budget down, Kirkwood arranged for merchandising tie-ins to attract unpaid extras to the sports arena on Monday. A foreign car was to be raffled off, in exchange for a plug-in of the film, and other merchandise was to be distributed at 15-minute intervals to keep the extras from leaving,” Variety reported during production. Extras also received meals from Kentucky Fried Chicken, one background player recalled.

In addition to his injuries during filming, Stallone suffered a broken rib during his final fight with Carl Weathers, while Weathers suffered a broken nose.

Did the studio really try to sabotage the production to make Stallone the star?

Stallone endeavored to run about nine miles on the first day of filming and 11 on the second, wearing Converse sneakers the entire time and giving himself a shin splint, according to the recent book “Going the Distance” about the making of “Rocky.” It’s unclear whether doctors actually told him to stay up for two weeks, as shown in “I Play Rocky.”

But Kubik said that even though the contract required a tight shooting schedule and budget, while giving producers the right to replace Stallone, it wouldn’t have made much sense to get rid of him. “I knew if they shot half the movie with him, they wouldn’t shoot for five days and then say we don’t like him,” Kubik said.

Stallone had a similar recollection of the contract when speaking to Howard Stern in 2005: “We have a 14-day window where we can fire you at any time and, more importantly, we can get it down to $900,000, all inclusive, and if you can do the thing in 30 days, OK. If not, it’s over.”

So even though United Artists wrote the contract with strict requirements in order to stay within budget, it would have been in no one’s best interest to try to get Stallone to quit after filming began.

Variety reported that director John Avildsen used numerous tactics to save money and stay on budget, including saving $200 by having Stallone provide voice work for three or four disguised voices coming from the bars and televisions.

Did Stallone call his father, Frank Stallone Sr., and ask him to appear in “Rocky?” »

Sylvester Stallone had a difficult relationship with his absent mother and abusive father Frank Sr., who could never seem to show his approval no matter what Sly accomplished. “I Play Rocky” shows him extending an olive branch by calling his father and asking if he can play a small role as the man who rings the bell at the end of the boxing match. Is this really how it happened?

Not so much, says Stallone in his book “The Steps: A Memoir.” As he tells it, when he showed up on set to shoot a scene, Frank Sr. was already waiting for him and insisted that he be given a role. There was only one problem, Stallone said in his memoir: the role had already been cast. “There was no reasoning with him, so with apologies, I let go of the timekeeper,” he recalls. When it came time to shoot, Frank Jr. missed his signal several times and…

Gn entert

Logo