Not all physical activity protects your brain, scientists warn

Clearing Brain Dementia
A major international study of more than 4.2 million people suggests that not all physical activities affect dementia risk equally. Credit: Shutterstock

Across 30 countries, researchers found that exercising in leisure time was linked to a lower risk of dementia, while physically demanding work was linked to a higher risk.

After spending a whole day on your feet, going for a walk or a bike ride may seem pointless. Yet new research suggests that being physically active at work doesn’t offer the same protection against dementia as exercising in your free time.

A major analysis of more than 4.2 million people found that those who were the most physically active in their leisure time had a 24% lower risk of dementia than those who were the least active. In contrast, physical activity at work was associated with a 20% higher risk.

The results, published in Lancet Public Healthraise an important question about the familiar advice to move more. If physical activity is good for the brain, why might its benefits depend on where and how it takes place?

Researchers at the University of Southern California (USC) examined this question by combining evidence from 74 cohort and case-control studies conducted in 30 countries. Participants were aged 45 to 93 years and were followed for a median of 10 years. During this time, researchers tracked diagnoses of dementia from all causes, including Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia.

The analysis was led by David Raichlen, professor of biological sciences and anthropology at the USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences. This is the first systematic investigation to determine whether the “physical activity paradox,” previously documented in cardiovascular research, also applies to dementia. The paradox describes how physically demanding occupations may not provide the same health benefits as recreational exercise and may even be associated with higher disease risk.

“The results challenge the long-held assumption that ‘every movement counts’ for brain health,” said Natan Feter, first author of the study, a postdoctoral researcher in the Raichlen Evolutionary Biology of Physical Activity Laboratory at USC and a researcher in the graduate program in epidemiology at the Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul in Brazil.

Why physical work differs from exercise

One possible explanation lies in what happens around physical activity itself. Walking, cycling, running, swimming, and playing sports during leisure time are generally activities that people can choose and adapt to their comfort level. They can also provide opportunities to socialize, relax and reduce stress.

Physically demanding work often presents very different circumstances. Workers may spend hours on their feet, lifting heavy objects repeatedly, or performing strenuous tasks with little opportunity for recovery. Unlike recreational training, these activities can occur alongside workplace risks and pressures that extend well beyond the physical exertion involved.

Manual occupations, for example, can expose workers to greater psychosocial stress, less control over their working conditions and higher levels of air and noise pollution. These factors have been independently linked to dementia risk. Workers may also struggle to find time or energy for recreational exercise, particularly when access to safe places for physical activity is limited.

For these reasons, the researchers believe it is unlikely that the higher risk of dementia associated with work activity results from the movement itself. Instead, working conditions and broader social environments surrounding physically demanding jobs may help explain the difference.

More activity, opposing risk models

The relationship also changed depending on the amount of activity people engaged in. Higher levels of leisure-time physical exercise were associated with increasingly lower risk of dementia, although the association eventually leveled off. Work activity followed the opposite trend, with dementia risk increasing alongside greater activity before reaching a similar plateau.

Not all forms of daily movement can be assessed with the same confidence. Physical activity within the home appears to be beneficial, although this conclusion comes from only one study. Active travel was associated with a slightly higher risk of dementia, but only two studies examined this relationship. The researchers stressed that more evidence is needed before definitive conclusions can be drawn about either activity.

There are also important limits to what the broader analysis can establish.

Because the studies were observational, the results cannot prove that physically demanding work causes dementia or that leisure-time physical exercise directly prevents it. Almost all studies relied on participants reporting their own physical activity, which can introduce memory and reporting errors. Most of the evidence also comes from high-income countries, despite expectations that low- and middle-income countries will see the largest increases in dementia cases in coming decades.

Even with these limitations, the contrasting associations remained after researchers took into account factors such as age, education and chronic illness. Multiple sensitivity analyses, which test whether the results hold under different analytical assumptions, produced consistent results. Feter said this consistency strengthens the case for a serious relationship.

Even sitting activities show different associations

The importance of context may extend beyond physical activity. In a related study published in Alzheimer’s and dementia The previous month, Raichlen, Feter and their colleagues examined the link between different sedentary behaviors and brain structure.

They found that mentally engaging activities performed while seated, such as working at a desk, were associated with greater volume in regions of the cerebral cortex compared to more passive activities, such as watching television. These regions included areas involved in executive function, which supports abilities such as planning and decision-making. Like the results on physical activity, these associations do not establish cause and effect.

The researchers stress that their findings should not discourage people from taking physically demanding jobs. Instead, they suggest that dementia prevention strategies need to consider the conditions in which people are active, including the opportunities they have to exercise outside of work.

“In other words, when it comes to protecting the brain, the context of physical activity may be as important as the movement itself,” Raichlen said. “Improving access to safe parks, walking trails and recreational facilities, ensuring people have enough free time to exercise, and reducing harmful exposures in the workplace may ultimately be as important as promoting physical activity itself.” »

Reference: “Domain-specific physical activity levels and dementia risk: systematic review and meta-analysis” by Natan Feter, Paula Iso-Markku, Tiladia Markarian, Dylan M Luong, Jack Gunnink, Natália Schröder, Eduardo Lucia Caputo, Jayne Feter, Anamika Nanda, Sarah Hourihan, Gustavo S da Silva, Ashley Ventura, Daniela Benzano Bumaguin, Yann C Klimentidis, Gene E Alexander, Daniel Umpierre, Pedro C Hallal, Airton José Rombaldi and David A Raichlen, September 2026, Lancet Public Health.
DOI: 10.1016/S2468-2667(26)00142-8

Never miss a major breakthrough: join the SciTechDaily newsletter.
Follow us on Google and Google News.

Gn Health

Logo